Banding: Difference between revisions
>Yandere-sliver (→Bands with other: clean up, replaced: {{TumblrRef|author=Mark Rosewater|URL= → {{EzTumblr|url=, |tumblr-title=Blogatog| → |) |
>Neoheart No edit summary |
||
| (40 intermediate revisions by 17 users not shown) | |||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
{{Infobox keyword | {{Infobox keyword | ||
| name2 = Bands with other [quality] | |||
| type = Static | | type = Static | ||
| first = Alpha | | first = Alpha | ||
| last = | | last = Mystery Booster | ||
| reminder = Any creatures with banding, and up to one without, can attack in a band. Bands are blocked as a group. If any creatures with banding you control are blocking or being blocked by a creature, you divide that creature's combat damage, not its controller, among any of the creatures it's being blocked by or is blocking. | | reminder = Any creatures with banding, and up to one without, can attack in a band. Bands are blocked as a group. If any creatures with banding you control are blocking or being blocked by a creature, you divide that creature's combat damage, not its controller, among any of the creatures it's being blocked by or is blocking. | ||
| | | reminder2=Any [quality] creatures can attack in a band as long as at least one has "bands with other [quality]." Bands are blocked as a group. If at least two [quality] creatures you control, one of which has "bands with other [quality]," are blocking or being blocked by the same creature, you divide that creature's combat damage, not its controller, among any of the creatures it's being blocked by or is blocking. | ||
| storm = 10 | |||
| storm_ref=<ref>{{EzTumblr|http://markrosewater.tumblr.com/post/162830448663/|title=Storm is a 10 on the Storm Scale, right?...|July 10, 2017}}</ref> | |||
| stats = {{stats|W=19|G=1|R=1|A=2|WU=1}} | |||
}} | }} | ||
'''Banding''' is a [[keyword ability]] | '''Banding''' is a [[keyword ability]] that lets a player form bands from their creatures and during combat takes the right to distribute damage from the opponent. It also changes the rules for attacking and blocking if a band is formed. It was introduced in ''[[Alpha]]'',<ref>{{DailyRef|feature/mechanically-inclined-2009-06-01|Mechanically Inclined|[[Brady Dommermuth]]|June 01, 2009}}</ref> and is no longer used on regular cards. | ||
==Description== | ==Description== | ||
By nature, banding is primarily a white ability (distributing damage – or another way of preventing damage by having it go to another creature). It was first printed in ''[[Alpha]]'' ("bands" was the original keyword used to represent the ability). | By nature, banding is primarily a white ability (distributing damage – or another way of preventing damage by having it go to another creature). It was first printed in ''[[Alpha]]'' ("bands" was the original keyword used to represent the ability). | ||
While acknowledging that banding was flavorful and effective if used properly, it has been effectively abandoned by designers for being overly confusing.<ref>{{ | While acknowledging that banding was flavorful and effective if used properly, it has been effectively abandoned by designers for being overly confusing.<ref>{{DailyRef|making-magic/baby-and-bathwater-2003-12-01|The Baby and the Bathwater|[[Mark Rosewater]]|Dec 1, 2003}}</ref> The last basic set in which banding appeared was the ''[[Fifth Edition]]'',<ref>{{DailyRef|making-magic/evergreen-eggs-ham-2015-06-08|Evergreen Eggs & Ham|[[Mark Rosewater]]|June 8, 2015}}</ref> and the last tournament-legal set was ''[[Weatherlight]]''. The most recent card to be printed with banding is {{card|Banding Sliver|Mystery Booster|MYSTPT}}. | ||
== | ===Attacking and blocking=== | ||
The rules needed to be different for attacking and blocking to express the effect properly, as the player takes on different roles in each situation. In both forms, the player with the banding creature assigns damage for both the banding creature and the creature(s) that are in combat with it, as opposed to each player assigning their own. | |||
== | ====Attacking==== | ||
= | |||
Any number of attacking creatures with banding can join together with up to one attacking creature without banding; the defending player must either block the entire band or allow it to be unblocked. If a blocking creature can block any one creature in the band, it can block the entire band. | Any number of attacking creatures with banding can join together with up to one attacking creature without banding; the defending player must either block the entire band or allow it to be unblocked. If a blocking creature can block any one creature in the band, it can block the entire band. | ||
{{examples| | {{examples|A given creature with banding attacks and bands with a creature with [[flying]]. The opposing player is then allowed to block the entire band with <c>Stratozeppelid</c>.}} | ||
A given creature with banding attacks and bands with a creature with [[flying]]. The opposing player is then allowed to block the entire band with <c>Stratozeppelid</c>. | |||
}} | |||
In addition, if an attacking creature with banding becomes blocked, the [[Player#Attacking player|attacking player]] chooses how damage from the blocking creatures is assigned. | In addition, if an attacking creature with banding becomes blocked, the [[Player#Attacking player|attacking player]] chooses how damage from the blocking creatures is assigned. | ||
===Blocking=== | ====Blocking==== | ||
When blocking, if at least one creature blocking an attacker has banding, then the defending player may choose how the creature blocked by the creature(s) with banding assigns combat damage. This | When blocking, if at least one creature blocking an attacker has banding, then the defending player may choose how the creature blocked by the creature(s) with banding assigns combat damage. | ||
==Rules== | |||
{{CR|glossary|Banding, “Bands with Other”}} | |||
{{CR|Banding}} | |||
===Bands with other=== | |||
A variant of banding, "'''bands with other'''" restricts banding to working with other creatures of a given [[quality]] (such as creatures that have a certain name). However, before the ''[[Magic 2010]]'' rules changes (which came several years later than any cards featuring the ability), it was probably the most counter-intuitive [[ability]] in the game, because instead of allowing banding with any number of creatures of the given type, it only allowed banding with creatures with the same "bands with other" ability or regular banding.<ref>{{DailyRef|absurd-or-ridiculous-you-decide-2002-03-06|Absurd or Ridiculous? You Decide|[[Mark Gottlieb]]|March 06, 2002}}</ref><ref>{{DailyRef|making-magic/make-no-mistake-2003-11-10-0|Make No Mistake|[[Mark Rosewater]]|November 10, 2003}}</ref><ref>{{DailyRef|arcana/friendly-goblin-2009-12-10|Friendly Goblin|[[Magic Arcana]]|Dec 10, 2009}}</ref> This was due to a stipulation in banding's rules that was not addressed in making "bands with others" {{-}} only one nonbanding creature can band, and the flavorful text "with other legends" was not a recognized phrase ruleswise. | |||
There are eight cards - all in the ''[[Legends]]'' set - with "bands with other" in the card text, though none have the actual ability "bands with other". The only creature card printed with "bands with other" ability is <c>Old Fogey</c> in ''[[Unhinged]]''. Five [[Utility land#Banding lands|banding lands]] can give the ability to [[legendary]] [[creatures]], and one creature can create [[token]]s with the ability (<c>Master of the Hunt</c>) and two cards can remove the ability (<c>Shelkin Brownie</c> and <c>Tolaria</c>). [[Mark Rosewater]] rates the mechanic an 11 out of 10 on the [[Storm Scale]].<ref>{{EzTumblr|http://markrosewater.tumblr.com/post/162852781728/i-remember-you-rated-one-mechanic-an-11-on-the|title=I remember you rated one mechanic an 11 on the storm scale. |July 11, 2017}}</ref> | |||
==Cards that grant banding== | ==Cards that grant banding== | ||
'''Enchantments''' | '''Enchantments''' | ||
*<c>Nature's Blessing </c> {{2}}{{G}}{{W}} | |||
''Enchanted creature'' | ''Enchanted creature'' | ||
*<c>Cooperation</c> {{2}}{{ | *<c>Cooperation</c> {{2}}{{W}} | ||
''[[Wall]] creatures you control'' | ''[[Wall]] creatures you control'' | ||
*<c>Fortified Area</c> {{1}}{{ | *<c>Fortified Area</c> {{1}}{{W}}{{W}} (walls only) | ||
'''Instant''' | '''Instant''' | ||
*<c>Formation</c> {{1}}{{ | *<c>Formation</c> {{1}}{{W}} | ||
'''Artifacts''' | '''Artifacts''' | ||
*<c>Helm of Chatzuk</c> {{1}} | *<c>Helm of Chatzuk</c> {{1}} | ||
*<c>Baton of Morale</c> {{2}} | *<c>Baton of Morale</c> {{2}} | ||
==Examples== | ==Examples== | ||
{{examples| | {{examples | ||
|<c>Benalish Hero</c> {{W}}<br/>Creature {{-}} Human Soldier<br/>1/1<br/>Banding ''(Any creatures with banding, and up to one without, can attack in a band. Bands are blocked as a group. If any creatures with banding you control are blocking or being blocked by a creature, you divide that creature's combat damage, not its controller, among any of the creatures it's being blocked by or is blocking.)'' | |||
|<c>Master of the Hunt</c> {{2}}{{G}}{{G}}<br/>Creature {{-}} Human<br/>2/2<br/>{{2}}{{G}}{{G}}: Create a 1/1 green Wolf creature token named Wolves of the Hunt. It has "bands with other creatures named Wolves of the Hunt." ''(Any creatures named Wolves of the Hunt can attack in a band as long as at least one has "bands with other creatures named Wolves of the Hunt." Bands are blocked as a group. If at least two creatures named Wolves of the Hunt you control, one of which has "bands with other creatures named Wolves of the Hunt," are blocking or being blocked by the same creature, you divide that creature's combat damage, not its controller, among any of the creatures it's being blocked by or is blocking.)'' | |||
}} | }} | ||
==External links== | ==External links== | ||
* Mark Rosewater | *{{WebRef|author=Mark Rosewater|date=November 26, 2014|url=http://media.wizards.com/2014/podcasts/magic/drivetowork179_banding.mp3|title=#179 - Banding|work=[[Drive to Work]]}} | ||
==References== | ==References== | ||
{{Reflist}} | {{Reflist}} | ||
{{ | {{Mechanics|keyword}} | ||
Latest revision as of 01:46, 5 July 2024
| Banding (Bands with other [quality]) | |
|---|---|
| Keyword Ability | |
| Type | Static |
| Introduced | Alpha |
| Last used | Mystery Booster |
| Reminder Text |
Banding (Any creatures with banding, and up to one without, can attack in a band. Bands are blocked as a group. If any creatures with banding you control are blocking or being blocked by a creature, you divide that creature's combat damage, not its controller, among any of the creatures it's being blocked by or is blocking.) Bands with other [quality] (Any [quality] creatures can attack in a band as long as at least one has "bands with other [quality]." Bands are blocked as a group. If at least two [quality] creatures you control, one of which has "bands with other [quality]," are blocking or being blocked by the same creature, you divide that creature's combat damage, not its controller, among any of the creatures it's being blocked by or is blocking.) |
| Storm Scale | 10[1] |
| Statistics |
24 cards  79.2%  4.2%  4.2%  4.2%  8.3% |
| Scryfall Search | |
| keyword:"Banding" | |
Banding is a keyword ability that lets a player form bands from their creatures and during combat takes the right to distribute damage from the opponent. It also changes the rules for attacking and blocking if a band is formed. It was introduced in Alpha,[2] and is no longer used on regular cards.
Description
By nature, banding is primarily a white ability (distributing damage – or another way of preventing damage by having it go to another creature). It was first printed in Alpha ("bands" was the original keyword used to represent the ability).
While acknowledging that banding was flavorful and effective if used properly, it has been effectively abandoned by designers for being overly confusing.[3] The last basic set in which banding appeared was the Fifth Edition,[4] and the last tournament-legal set was Weatherlight. The most recent card to be printed with banding is Banding Sliver (Mystery Booster).
Attacking and blocking
The rules needed to be different for attacking and blocking to express the effect properly, as the player takes on different roles in each situation. In both forms, the player with the banding creature assigns damage for both the banding creature and the creature(s) that are in combat with it, as opposed to each player assigning their own.
Attacking
Any number of attacking creatures with banding can join together with up to one attacking creature without banding; the defending player must either block the entire band or allow it to be unblocked. If a blocking creature can block any one creature in the band, it can block the entire band.
Example
A given creature with banding attacks and bands with a creature with flying. The opposing player is then allowed to block the entire band with Stratozeppelid.
In addition, if an attacking creature with banding becomes blocked, the attacking player chooses how damage from the blocking creatures is assigned.
Blocking
When blocking, if at least one creature blocking an attacker has banding, then the defending player may choose how the creature blocked by the creature(s) with banding assigns combat damage.
Rules
From the glossary of the Comprehensive Rules (June 7, 2024—Modern Horizons 3)
- Banding, “Bands with Other”
- Banding is a keyword ability that modifies the rules for declaring attackers and assigning combat damage. “Bands with other” is a specialized version of the ability. See rule 702.22, “Banding.”
From the Comprehensive Rules (June 7, 2024—Modern Horizons 3)
- 702.22. Banding
- 702.22a Banding is a static ability that modifies the rules for combat.
- 702.22b “Bands with other” is a special form of banding. If an effect causes a permanent to lose banding, the permanent loses all “bands with other” abilities as well.
- 702.22c As a player declares attackers, they may declare that one or more attacking creatures with banding and up to one attacking creature without banding (even if it has “bands with other”) are all in a “band.” They may also declare that one or more attacking [quality] creatures with “bands with other [quality]” and any number of other attacking [quality] creatures are all in a band. A player may declare as many attacking bands as they want, but each creature may be a member of only one of them. (Defending players can’t declare bands but may use banding in a different way; see rule 702.22j.)
- 702.22d All creatures in an attacking band must attack the same player, planeswalker, or battle.
- 702.22e Once an attacking band has been announced, it lasts for the rest of combat, even if something later removes banding or “bands with other” from one or more of the creatures in the band.
- 702.22f An attacking creature that’s removed from combat is also removed from the band it was in.
- 702.22g Banding doesn’t cause attacking creatures to share abilities, nor does it remove any abilities. The attacking creatures in a band are separate permanents.
- 702.22h If an attacking creature becomes blocked by a creature, each other creature in the same band as the attacking creature becomes blocked by that same blocking creature.
Example: A player attacks with a band consisting of a creature with flying and a creature with swampwalk. The defending player, who controls a Swamp, can block the flying creature if able. If they do, then the creature with swampwalk will also become blocked by the blocking creature(s).
- 702.22i If one member of a band would become blocked due to an effect, the entire band becomes blocked.
- 702.22j During the combat damage step, if an attacking creature is being blocked by a creature with banding, or by both a [quality] creature with “bands with other [quality]” and another [quality] creature, the defending player (rather than the active player) chooses how the attacking creature’s damage is assigned. That player can divide that creature’s combat damage as they choose among any creatures blocking it. This is an exception to the procedure described in rule 510.1c.
- 702.22k During the combat damage step, if a blocking creature is blocking a creature with banding, or both a [quality] creature with “bands with other [quality]” and another [quality] creature, the active player (rather than the defending player) chooses how the blocking creature’s damage is assigned. That player can divide that creature’s combat damage as they choose among any creatures it’s blocking. This is an exception to the procedure described in rule 510.1d.
- 702.22m Multiple instances of banding on the same creature are redundant. Multiple instances of “bands with other” of the same kind on the same creature are redundant.
Bands with other
A variant of banding, "bands with other" restricts banding to working with other creatures of a given quality (such as creatures that have a certain name). However, before the Magic 2010 rules changes (which came several years later than any cards featuring the ability), it was probably the most counter-intuitive ability in the game, because instead of allowing banding with any number of creatures of the given type, it only allowed banding with creatures with the same "bands with other" ability or regular banding.[5][6][7] This was due to a stipulation in banding's rules that was not addressed in making "bands with others" — only one nonbanding creature can band, and the flavorful text "with other legends" was not a recognized phrase ruleswise.
There are eight cards - all in the Legends set - with "bands with other" in the card text, though none have the actual ability "bands with other". The only creature card printed with "bands with other" ability is Old Fogey in Unhinged. Five banding lands can give the ability to legendary creatures, and one creature can create tokens with the ability (Master of the Hunt) and two cards can remove the ability (Shelkin Brownie and Tolaria). Mark Rosewater rates the mechanic an 11 out of 10 on the Storm Scale.[8]
Cards that grant banding
Enchantments
Enchanted creature
Wall creatures you control
- Fortified Area
(walls only)
Instant
Artifacts
Examples
Example 1
Benalish Hero
Creature — Human Soldier
1/1
Banding (Any creatures with banding, and up to one without, can attack in a band. Bands are blocked as a group. If any creatures with banding you control are blocking or being blocked by a creature, you divide that creature's combat damage, not its controller, among any of the creatures it's being blocked by or is blocking.)
Example 2
Master of the Hunt 
Creature — Human
2/2: Create a 1/1 green Wolf creature token named Wolves of the Hunt. It has "bands with other creatures named Wolves of the Hunt." (Any creatures named Wolves of the Hunt can attack in a band as long as at least one has "bands with other creatures named Wolves of the Hunt." Bands are blocked as a group. If at least two creatures named Wolves of the Hunt you control, one of which has "bands with other creatures named Wolves of the Hunt," are blocking or being blocked by the same creature, you divide that creature's combat damage, not its controller, among any of the creatures it's being blocked by or is blocking.)
External links
- Mark Rosewater (November 26, 2014). "#179 - Banding". Drive to Work.
References
- ↑ Mark Rosewater (July 10, 2017). "Storm is a 10 on the Storm Scale, right?...". Blogatog. Tumblr.
- ↑ Brady Dommermuth (June 01, 2009). "Mechanically Inclined". magicthegathering.com. Wizards of the Coast.
- ↑ Mark Rosewater (Dec 1, 2003). "The Baby and the Bathwater". magicthegathering.com. Wizards of the Coast.
- ↑ Mark Rosewater (June 8, 2015). "Evergreen Eggs & Ham". magicthegathering.com. Wizards of the Coast.
- ↑ Mark Gottlieb (March 06, 2002). "Absurd or Ridiculous? You Decide". magicthegathering.com. Wizards of the Coast.
- ↑ Mark Rosewater (November 10, 2003). "Make No Mistake". magicthegathering.com. Wizards of the Coast.
- ↑ Magic Arcana (Dec 10, 2009). "Friendly Goblin". magicthegathering.com. Wizards of the Coast.
- ↑ Mark Rosewater (July 11, 2017). "I remember you rated one mechanic an 11 on the storm scale.". Blogatog. Tumblr.