Filter land: Difference between revisions
(Changed "Masters" to "Horizons" and changed the link from "Modern_Masters" to "Modern_Horizons") |
>Passionlip No edit summary |
||
(30 intermediate revisions by 13 users not shown) | |||
Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
'''Filter lands''' can refer to two different sets of [[dual land]]s.<ref>{{DailyRef|making-magic/get-ready-dual-2017-02-27|Get Ready to Dual|[[Mark Rosewater]]|February 27, 2017}}</ref> Their name describes the ability to take one mana and turn it into a combination of two [[color]]ed [[mana]]. | '''Filter lands''' can refer to two different sets of [[dual land]]s.<ref>{{DailyRef|making-magic/get-ready-dual-2017-02-27|Get Ready to Dual|[[Mark Rosewater]]|February 27, 2017}}</ref> Their name describes the ability to take one mana and turn it into a combination of two [[color]]ed [[mana]]. Some lower powered and older filter lands can generate more color but don't generate net mana, making them generally poor but lower rarity mana fixers. | ||
== | ==Original filter lands== | ||
The original filter lands were a [[cycle]] of lands that appeared in ''[[Odyssey]]''. They each have an activation cost of {{1}} and produce two mana of different colors of an allied color pair. | ===Allied colored from ''Odyssey''=== | ||
The original filter lands were a [[cycle]] of lands that appeared in ''[[Odyssey]]''. They each have an activation cost of {{1}} and produce two mana of different colors of an allied color pair. While better than some filter lands due to being mana-positive, the inability to tap for {{C}} mana meant that they could leave a player stranded without mana. | |||
*<c>Skycloud Expanse</c> {{W}}{{U}} | *<c>Skycloud Expanse</c> {{W}}{{U}} | ||
*<c>Darkwater Catacombs</c> {{U}}{{B}} | *<c>Darkwater Catacombs</c> {{U}}{{B}} | ||
*<c>Shadowblood Ridge</c> {{B}}{{R}} | *<c>Shadowblood Ridge</c> {{B}}{{ R}} | ||
*<c>Mossfire Valley</c> {{R}}{{G}} | *<c>Mossfire Valley</c> {{R}}{{G}} | ||
*<c>Sungrass Prairie</c> {{G}}{{W}} | *<c>Sungrass Prairie</c> {{G}}{{W}} | ||
===Enemy colored from ''Fallout''=== | |||
Twenty-three years after the introduction of the original filter lands, the cycle was completed with the printing of the remaining five enemy color filter lands in [[Universes Beyond]] ''[[Fallout]]''.<ref>{{TwitterRef|GavinVerhey|1760121582280929646|author=[[Gavin Verhey]]|title=One thing you'll find in MTGxFallout for the first time: the enemy color counterparts to the Odyssey Filterlands!|date=February 21, 2024}}</ref> They immediately were reused in [[Universes Within]] ''[[Thunder Junction Commander]]''.<ref>{{YouTubeRef|2-QtZEcTzZ0|Unfinished Land Cycles in Commander Decks?? A Mana Chat! |channel=[[Good Morning Magic]]|date=April 23, 2024}}</ref> | |||
*{{card|Desolate Mire||PIP}} {{W}}{{B}} | |||
*{{card|Ferrous Lake||PIP}} {{U}}{{R}} | |||
*{{card|Viridescent Bog||PIP}} {{B}}{{G}} | |||
*{{card|Sunscorched Divide||PIP}} {{R}}{{W}} | |||
*{{card|Overflowing Basin||PIP}} {{G}}{{U}} | |||
==Shadowmoor/Eventide filter lands== | ==Shadowmoor/Eventide filter lands== | ||
Newer filter lands were previewed in ''[[Future Sight]]''. The [[cycle]] of ten dual lands was finished in the sets ''[[Shadowmoor]]'' and ''[[Eventide]]''. In Shadowmoor the cycle of allied colored lands | Newer filter lands were previewed in ''[[Future Sight]]''. The [[cycle]] of ten dual lands was finished in the sets ''[[Shadowmoor]]'' and ''[[Eventide]]''. In Shadowmoor the cycle of allied-colored lands was printed, while Eventide had the cycle of enemy-colored lands. They each take one mana of two possible colors and produce two mana of any combination of the two colors that can be paid. They can also tap for {{C}} mana, avoiding the above issue. | ||
They were reprinted in ''[[Oath of the Gatewatch]]: [[Zendikar Expeditions]]'' | They were reprinted in ''[[Oath of the Gatewatch]]: [[Zendikar Expeditions]]'' and ''[[Double Masters]]'' | ||
*''Future Sight'' {{-}} [[Timeshifted]] ''Shadowmoor'' preview | *''Future Sight'' {{-}} [[Timeshifted]] ''Shadowmoor'' preview | ||
Line 20: | Line 29: | ||
*<c>Sunken Ruins</c> {{U/B}} | *<c>Sunken Ruins</c> {{U/B}} | ||
*<c>Graven Cairns</c> {{B/R}} | *<c>Graven Cairns</c> {{B/R}} | ||
*<c>Fire- | *<c>Fire-Lit Thicket</c> {{R/G}} | ||
*<c>Wooded Bastion</c> {{G/W}} | *<c>Wooded Bastion</c> {{G/W}} | ||
Line 46: | Line 55: | ||
* <c>Boros Signet</c> ({{R}}{{W}}) | * <c>Boros Signet</c> ({{R}}{{W}}) | ||
* <c>Simic Signet</c> ({{G}}{{U}}) | * <c>Simic Signet</c> ({{G}}{{U}}) | ||
==Original triple lands== | |||
The earliest [[triple land]] cycle from ''[[Homelands]]'' which produces three colors of mana conditionally as follows: | |||
:{{T}}: Add {{C}}. | |||
:{{1}},{{T}}: Add M. | |||
:{{2}},{{T}}: Add N or O. | |||
where N and O are the [[allied color]]s of M. | |||
*<c>Aysen Abbey</c> {{W}} ({{mana|GU}}) | |||
*<c>Wizards' School</c> {{U}} ({{mana|WB}}) | |||
*<c>Castle Sengir</c> {{B}} ({{mana|UR}}) | |||
*<c>Koskun Keep</c> {{R}} ({{mana|BG}}) | |||
*<c>An-Havva Township</c> {{G}} ({{mana|RW}}) | |||
By a looser definition, much like some of the lands listed below, these too are filter lands but are strictly worse than several of them. | |||
==Rainbow filter lands== | |||
Introduced in ''[[Lorwyn]]'', <c>Shimmering Grotto</c> has the ability "{{1}}, {{T}}: Add one mana of any color." alongside tapping for {{C}}, making them strictly better than older filter lands <c>School of the Unseen</c> and <c>Henge of Ramos</c>. This pair of abilities is the most common filter land template, and with reprints (plus <c>Unknown Shores</c>, which has one more premier set printing) turn up often in sets as a bad mana fixer where <c>Evolving Wilds</c> is potentially too useful. Newer common versions experiment with other minor upsides. | |||
The following lands follow this template, with the rare ones having a powerful secondary ability. | |||
===Common=== | |||
* <c>Cave of Temptation</c> from ''[[Modern Horizons]]'' {{-}} Sacrifices to add two +1/+1 counters for {{4}}. | |||
**<c>Captivating Cave</c> from ''[[The Lost Caverns of Ixalan]]'' {{-}} The same, but is a [[Cave]]. | |||
* <c>Crystal Grotto</c> from ''[[Dominaria United]]'' {{-}} Scries 1 when it enters. | |||
* <c>Heap Gate</c> from ''[[Commander Legends: Battle for Baldur's Gate]]'' {{-}} Is a [[Gate]], can also create [[Treasure]]. | |||
* <c>Painted Bluffs</c> from ''[[Amonkhet]]'' {{-}} Is a [[Desert]]. | |||
**<c>Conduit Pylons</c> from ''[[Outlaws of Thunder Junction]]'' {{-}} The same, but [[Surveil]]s 1 when it enters. | |||
* <c>Shimmering Grotto</c> from ''[[Lorwyn]]'' | |||
* <c>Study Hall</c> from ''[[Commander 2021]]'' {{-}} Scries if used to cast their [[Commander]]. | |||
* <c>Unknown Shores</c> from ''[[Theros]]'' | |||
===Rare=== | |||
*<c>Abstergo Entertainment</c> from ''[[Assassin's Creed]]'' {{-}} Returns a historic permanent from a graveyard to hand at the cost of {{3}} and exiling itself and all graveyards. | |||
*<c>Hall of Oracles</c> from ''[[Strixhaven: School of Mages]]'' {{-}} Tap to add a +1/+1 counter to a creature, after casting an instant or sorcery. | |||
*<c>Hall of Tagsin</c> from ''[[The Brothers' War]]'' {{-}} Creates [[powerstone]]s for {{4}}. | |||
*<c>Guildmages' Forum</c> from ''[[Guilds of Ravnica]]'' {{-}} Puts +1/+1 counters on multicolor creatures cast with filtered mana. | |||
*<c>The Mycosynth Gardens</c> from ''[[Phyrexia: All Will Be One]]'' {{-}} Can turn itself into an artifact controlled | |||
*<c>Planar Nexus</c> from ''[[MH3 Commander]]'' {{-}} Is all nonbasic land types | |||
*<c>Talon Gates of Madara</c> from ''[[MH3 Commander]]'' {{-}} Is a gate that phases out a creature on entry and can put itself onto the battlefield from the hand for {{4}}. | |||
==Other filter lands== | ==Other filter lands== | ||
There are a few other filter lands | There are a few other filter lands that don't belong in any cycle: | ||
*<c>Baldur's Gate</c> from ''[[Commander Legends: Battle for Baldur's Gate]]'' {{-}} Adds mana of a chosen color for each of your other Gates for {{2}}. | |||
*<c>Cabal Coffers</c> from ''[[Torment]]'' {{-}} Adds {{B}} for each Swamp you control for {{2}}. | *<c>Cabal Coffers</c> from ''[[Torment]]'' {{-}} Adds {{B}} for each Swamp you control for {{2}}. | ||
*<c>Cabal Stronghold</c> from ''[[Dominaria]]'' {{-}} Adds {{B}} for each basic Swamp you control for {{3}}. | |||
*<c>Cascading Cataracts</c> from ''[[Amonkhet]]'' {{-}} Adds five mana in any combination of colors for {{5}}. | |||
*<c>Castle Garenbrig</c> is an unusual case, as it belongs to a cycle in [[Throne of Eldraine]], but the others do different effects. It filters {{2}}{{G}}{{G}} into six {{G}} for creature abilities or spells. | |||
*<c>Crypt of the Eternals</c> from ''[[Hour of Devastation]]'' {{-}} Adds {{U}}, {{B}}, or {{R}} for {{1}}. | |||
*<c>Crystal Quarry</c> from ''[[Odyssey]]'' {{-}} Adds {{mana|WUBRG}} for {{5}}. | *<c>Crystal Quarry</c> from ''[[Odyssey]]'' {{-}} Adds {{mana|WUBRG}} for {{5}}. | ||
*<c>Great Hall of the Citadel</c> {{-}} Adds two mana of any color for {{1}} only to cast legendary spells. | |||
*<c>Henge of Ramos</c> from ''[[Mercadian Masques]]'' {{-}} Adds one mana of any color for {{2}}. | *<c>Henge of Ramos</c> from ''[[Mercadian Masques]]'' {{-}} Adds one mana of any color for {{2}}. | ||
*<c>Interplanar Beacon</c> from ''[[War of the Spark]]'' {{-}} Adds two mana of different colors for {{1}}, but to cast only planeswalkers. | |||
*<c>Nykthos, Shrine to Nyx</c> from ''[[Theros]]'' {{-}} Adds an amount of mana of a chosen color equal to your devotion to that color for {{2}}. | |||
*<c>Opal Palace</c> from ''[[Commander 2013]]'' {{-}} Adds one mana of any color in your [[Commander (designation)|Commander's]] color identity for {{1}}. | |||
*<c>School of the Unseen</c> from ''[[Alliances]]'' {{-}} Adds one mana of any color for {{2}}. | *<c>School of the Unseen</c> from ''[[Alliances]]'' {{-}} Adds one mana of any color for {{2}}. | ||
*<c> | *<c>Tarnation Vista</c> from ''[[Outlaws of Thunder Junction|The Big Score]]'' {{-}} Adds one of the appropriate mana for each monocolored permanent for {{1}}. | ||
==References== | ==References== | ||
{{Reflist}} | {{Reflist}} | ||
{{lands}} | {{lands}} |
Latest revision as of 11:39, 30 June 2024
Filter lands can refer to two different sets of dual lands.[1] Their name describes the ability to take one mana and turn it into a combination of two colored mana. Some lower powered and older filter lands can generate more color but don't generate net mana, making them generally poor but lower rarity mana fixers.
Original filter lands
Allied colored from Odyssey
The original filter lands were a cycle of lands that appeared in Odyssey. They each have an activation cost of and produce two mana of different colors of an allied color pair. While better than some filter lands due to being mana-positive, the inability to tap for mana meant that they could leave a player stranded without mana.
Enemy colored from Fallout
Twenty-three years after the introduction of the original filter lands, the cycle was completed with the printing of the remaining five enemy color filter lands in Universes Beyond Fallout.[2] They immediately were reused in Universes Within Thunder Junction Commander.[3]
Shadowmoor/Eventide filter lands
Newer filter lands were previewed in Future Sight. The cycle of ten dual lands was finished in the sets Shadowmoor and Eventide. In Shadowmoor the cycle of allied-colored lands was printed, while Eventide had the cycle of enemy-colored lands. They each take one mana of two possible colors and produce two mana of any combination of the two colors that can be paid. They can also tap for mana, avoiding the above issue. They were reprinted in Oath of the Gatewatch: Zendikar Expeditions and Double Masters
- Future Sight — Timeshifted Shadowmoor preview
Allied colored from Shadowmoor
Enemy colored from Eventide
Ravnica Signets
During Ravnica block a cycle of ten Mana Stones were printed which have abilities similar to the original filter lands. These artifacts cost to cast and can be tapped to filter into two mana of two different colors.
Allied colored
- Azorius Signet ()
- Dimir Signet ()
- Rakdos Signet ()
- Gruul Signet ()
- Selesnya Signet ()
Enemy colored
- Orzhov Signet ()
- Izzet Signet ()
- Golgari Signet ()
- Boros Signet ()
- Simic Signet ()
Original triple lands
The earliest triple land cycle from Homelands which produces three colors of mana conditionally as follows:
- : Add .
- ,: Add M.
- ,: Add N or O.
where N and O are the allied colors of M.
- Aysen Abbey ()
- Wizards' School ()
- Castle Sengir ()
- Koskun Keep ()
- An-Havva Township ()
By a looser definition, much like some of the lands listed below, these too are filter lands but are strictly worse than several of them.
Rainbow filter lands
Introduced in Lorwyn, Shimmering Grotto has the ability ", : Add one mana of any color." alongside tapping for , making them strictly better than older filter lands School of the Unseen and Henge of Ramos. This pair of abilities is the most common filter land template, and with reprints (plus Unknown Shores, which has one more premier set printing) turn up often in sets as a bad mana fixer where Evolving Wilds is potentially too useful. Newer common versions experiment with other minor upsides. The following lands follow this template, with the rare ones having a powerful secondary ability.
Common
- Cave of Temptation from Modern Horizons — Sacrifices to add two +1/+1 counters for .
- Captivating Cave from The Lost Caverns of Ixalan — The same, but is a Cave.
- Crystal Grotto from Dominaria United — Scries 1 when it enters.
- Heap Gate from Commander Legends: Battle for Baldur's Gate — Is a Gate, can also create Treasure.
- Painted Bluffs from Amonkhet — Is a Desert.
- Conduit Pylons from Outlaws of Thunder Junction — The same, but Surveils 1 when it enters.
- Shimmering Grotto from Lorwyn
- Study Hall from Commander 2021 — Scries if used to cast their Commander.
- Unknown Shores from Theros
Rare
- Abstergo Entertainment from Assassin's Creed — Returns a historic permanent from a graveyard to hand at the cost of and exiling itself and all graveyards.
- Hall of Oracles from Strixhaven: School of Mages — Tap to add a +1/+1 counter to a creature, after casting an instant or sorcery.
- Hall of Tagsin from The Brothers' War — Creates powerstones for .
- Guildmages' Forum from Guilds of Ravnica — Puts +1/+1 counters on multicolor creatures cast with filtered mana.
- The Mycosynth Gardens from Phyrexia: All Will Be One — Can turn itself into an artifact controlled
- Planar Nexus from MH3 Commander — Is all nonbasic land types
- Talon Gates of Madara from MH3 Commander — Is a gate that phases out a creature on entry and can put itself onto the battlefield from the hand for .
Other filter lands
There are a few other filter lands that don't belong in any cycle:
- Baldur's Gate from Commander Legends: Battle for Baldur's Gate — Adds mana of a chosen color for each of your other Gates for .
- Cabal Coffers from Torment — Adds for each Swamp you control for .
- Cabal Stronghold from Dominaria — Adds for each basic Swamp you control for .
- Cascading Cataracts from Amonkhet — Adds five mana in any combination of colors for .
- Castle Garenbrig is an unusual case, as it belongs to a cycle in Throne of Eldraine, but the others do different effects. It filters into six for creature abilities or spells.
- Crypt of the Eternals from Hour of Devastation — Adds , , or for .
- Crystal Quarry from Odyssey — Adds for .
- Great Hall of the Citadel — Adds two mana of any color for only to cast legendary spells.
- Henge of Ramos from Mercadian Masques — Adds one mana of any color for .
- Interplanar Beacon from War of the Spark — Adds two mana of different colors for , but to cast only planeswalkers.
- Nykthos, Shrine to Nyx from Theros — Adds an amount of mana of a chosen color equal to your devotion to that color for .
- Opal Palace from Commander 2013 — Adds one mana of any color in your Commander's color identity for .
- School of the Unseen from Alliances — Adds one mana of any color for .
- Tarnation Vista from The Big Score — Adds one of the appropriate mana for each monocolored permanent for .
References
- ↑ Mark Rosewater (February 27, 2017). "Get Ready to Dual". magicthegathering.com. Wizards of the Coast.
- ↑ Gavin Verhey (February 21, 2024). "One thing you'll find in MTGxFallout for the first time: the enemy color counterparts to the Odyssey Filterlands!". Twitter.
- ↑ Unfinished Land Cycles in Commander Decks?? A Mana Chat! (Video). Good Morning Magic. YouTube (April 23, 2024).