Talk:Rebecca Guay
I agree with tagging the cards, but what does the c|<cardname> do? Right now it pops you to an edit screen then pops you back. --Shadowin 15:18, 10 April 2006 (CDT)
- you have to hit ctrl+F5 first, to make your browser happy, and then if you have any anti-popup stuff running, tell it to allow popups from this site. Then, it'll open Gatherer windows for the cards.VestDan 15:57, 10 April 2006 (CDT)
- Eventually I will get rid of the "dummy" window that you sometimes see flash by, but it will require coding in a deeper location. I'll talk to Brion VIBBER.Voice of AllTalk 16:04, 10 April 2006 (CDT)
Do we really need the list of cards & the Complete card list from Gatherer link at the bottom? Kind of redundant. I say no, there shouldn't be a list. No other artist on here has a list of cards plus their link to the gatherer, they just have the link. --GeoMike 12:36, 18 December 2007 (UTC)
- I agree. We can create such lists for other artists as well, but they shouldn't be in the article. At most in the subpage. For now, I say kill it. --MORT (T) 20:41, 18 December 2007 (UTC)
Mirrodin? I know she didn't have any cards in that set, but I thought it was her absence from Legions and Scourge that got fans in an uproar.--Filby 00:03, 22 May 2008 (PDT)
- I don't have the exact reference, but I remember the Art Director at that time said her art was too organic, girlish, and cute for the metallic setting of Mirrodin. --Japoniano 09:17, 22 May 2008 (PDT)
- I'm pretty sure it was the tail-end of the Odyssey block he was talking about, what with all the freaky mutant critters running around.--Filby 11:57, 22 May 2008 (PDT)
Rewrite
I massively rewrote this entire article. Added the citations and corrected the entire controversy thing that was for some reason attributed falsely to Mirrodin. Added a gallery as well, but I'm not really sure what artworks of hers I'd consider necessary, iconic, or noteworthy since her cards are so similar in style and blend naturally together.--Cashew 08:08, 7 September 2010 (UTC)
Gallery Highlights
| Artwork | Quality | Relevance | Description | Replace? |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Channel | Very High | Medium | Alternate art of an iconic card. From The Vault: Exiled | Not recommended |
| Elvish Piper | High | High | Fairly well known elvish card. Artwork is representative of her depictions of both green spells and elf creatures. | Not recommended |
| Gaea's Blessing | Very High | High | Artwork is of a well recognized and powerful green card. Artwork is representative of her Golden Age of Illustration inspirations. | Not recommended |
| Persecute Artist | Low | Very High | Artwork is an un-Card that parodies the controversy revolving around her. | Only to improve quality |
| Sustaining Spirit | Medium | Medium | An angel spirit and one of her first illustrations. Slightly representative of her white spells and angel creatures. | To improve quality or relevance. |
| Sylvan Echoes | High | High | Card is not memorable. However it is highly impressionistic and relays that side of her artwork very well. | Not recommended. |
| Vitalizing Cascade | Low | Medium | A non-memorable Stream of Life card. Represents her depiction of the female form and Golden Age of Illustration. | To improve quality or relevance. |
| Wilderness Hypnotist | High | Medium | A non-memorable Merfolk from Shadowmoor. It is the anti-thesis of her normal style which makes it slightly unique. See also Bandage, Bitterblossom, Enslaved Scout, Dark Ritual, et al | To improve relevance. |
Use this as a quick way to determine which artworks need improvement or replacement.