Shaw v. Wizards of The Coast

From MTG Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Shaw et al. v. Wizards of The Coast, LLC was a class-action lawsuit filed in April 2016 against Wizards of the Coast. Adam Shaw, along with fellow judges Peter Golightly, Justin Turner, Joshua Stansfield, and a putative class of unnamed additional individuals sought to recover unpaid wages that they claimed were owed for their work judging tournaments.[1]

In the previous year, another judge, Paul Yale, had filed suit for similar claims (Paul Yale v. Wizards of the Coast LLC[2]), but his case received less notice. Yale's case was dismissed in 2017, with leave to amend.[3] The two cases were settled together in 2018, with modest settlements paid to each judge.

Outcome

Shaw et al. claimed damages exceeding $5M.[4] After three years of litigation, Shaw and Yale were jointly settled in December 2018. The plaintiffs received a total settlement of $21,250, with each of the original five plaintiffs receiving $2,500. Other plaintiffs who joined the case later received $500.[5][6]

External links

References

  1. ICv2 (April 22, 2016). "Are 'Magic' Judges Employees?"
  2. Yale v. Wizards of the Coast LLC. CourtListener (Dec 31, 2015).
  3. Cyrus Farivar (Aug 24, 2017). "Judge tosses case brought by Magic: the Gathering judge who wants to be paid". Ars Technica.
  4. Jonathan Lurie (May 2, 2016). "Judges Judging Judges: Will a Court Rule Magic the Gathering Judges are Employees?". LegalMatch.
  5. Joint Motion for Settlement. CourtListener (Oct 15, 2018).
  6. Order granting Motion for Settlement. CourtListener (Dec 6, 2018).