MTG Wiki:Notability

From MTG Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search

In wiki-speak, notability is the core quality that determines whether a topic should have an article. In addition to Wikipedia's general notability guideline, the following subject-specific notability guidelines apply here.

Wizards of the Coast as a source

Determining notability usually starts with finding reliable, independent sources.

Wizards of the Coast is, by definition, the most reliable source for many of the topics covered on MTG Wiki. Often, Wizards is the only source. As long as Wizards sources provide sufficient detail to write a full article, that article can rely on only those sources. If little information is available, it might be appropriate to place that topic in a list, rather than an article.

Wizards is not an independent source. Wizards sources are fundamentally biased in favor of the company, and as a result are not always reliable. When relying on Wizards sources, take care to maintain a neutral point of view and avoid merely promoting Wizards and its products.

Magic: the Gathering

Every article on MTG Wiki must be related to Magic: the Gathering in some non-trivial manner.

Game terms

Named game mechanics are implicitly notable. Unnamed mechanics demand some proof of notability.

Individual cards are generally not notable. The strategies and deck archetypes that center around them may be.

Fictional elements

Characters in the game's fiction are notable. Characters with only trivial mention may not warrant an independent article, but can still be documented in a list of secondary characters for the setting in which they appear.

Products

Every Magic product released, previewed, or even cancelled by Wizards of the Coast is notable, as long as an adequate source exists describing it.

Specific third-party products, even licensed products, are often not. Third-party manufacturers may be notable.

Universes Beyond

Each Universes Beyond (UB) product warrants an article for the product itself. Named game mechanics introduced in those products, such as keywords or creature types, are also notable.

Articles about Universes Beyond characters, worlds, and other fiction elements are outside of the scope of the MTG Wiki. Articles for these subjects should not be created without first seeking consensus from other editors.

Community websites

Community websites are rarely covered by each other, or by independent sources. Notability is determined by consensus.

People

People can become notable by winning certain major tournaments, or participating in the development of Magic as an employee or credited artistic contractor of Wizards of the Coast.

Wizards of the Coast employees

All Magic designers and developers are notable. Artists are also notable.

Content creators

Creators like bloggers and streamers are rarely covered by each other, or by independent sources. Notability is determined by consensus.

Professional players

Players awarded any of the following are notable by virtue of that accomplishment.

Pro Tour Runners Up, winners of an Arena Championship, and winners of Magic Online Champions Showcases may also be notable.

Similar achievements in older professional play structures also confer notability.

Regional Champions are not notable.