Talk:Loyalty counter
Interaction section
I don't know that we really want cards that open-endedly interact with counters, like Clockspinning and Vorinclex, Monstrous Raider here. If we do, we might want to consider having subsections for specific loyalty counter interaction vs. open-ended counter interaction. I think we could add just about everything from the linked Scryfall search, though at that point, listing them all seems redundant... --BlackDiamondDragon (talk) 19:25, 13 July 2021 (UTC)
- I'm not super opinionated on this except that once a list is over a dozen or two cards, it's hard to maintain and starts to seem better to leave for searches. With that said, it's quite easy to search for "loyalty", but much harder to search for "counters but not a specific kind of counter on this one card". With THAT said, the right place for the general counter interaction list is probably Counter (marker), not this page. I might move that subsection from this page to the general one later, if there are no objections, but I'm open to other thoughts. - jerodast (talk) 11:59, 4 January 2022 (UTC)
Merge with Loyalty article
Glancing at this and Loyalty, there isn't really much content on either of them, and they're nearly the same thing anyway. I don't see a huge reason not to just combine them - the concept of loyalty and physical mechanic of tracking loyalty can live happily on one page.
Not sure which title should be the main one. Probably just "loyalty", even though far more cards refer to "loyalty counters" than loyalty without referring to either the counters or "loyalty abilities".
That said, not planning to focus on it anytime soon, so just "for your consideration" for now.