Talk:Sliver/Trivia

From MTG Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Hey, I was adding the P/T of the metallic sliver with the modification added by simply beeing more slivers on the board if we consider the test cards ones. And those P/T are actually different than the one currently present and the update got removed as "redondant" while it was .... not ?

Like, can we clarify that rather than go in an edit war ?


EDIT: And now the current P/T are kinda wrong : the do consider the tests cards ones while they are placed before the line "if we consider test cards".

^ Why is this still here when it seems to have been resolved? (v see the below section)

^^ Apparently, someone else corrected it too, while adding the Sliver Gravemother, so I suppose it wasn't only me. (For the sake of clarity, I am the person that posted the comment on top of the discussion about having two lines of P/T with and without test cards, however I'm not the one adding back the second line of P/T under the test cards)

P/T with Legion

The P/T should be correct until we see more Slivers from CMM (127/124 Legion and Swamp not including the test cards (110 slivers))

Metallic Sliver and Encore

Because Metallic Sliver's mana value is 1, the encore value should be {1} rather than {X}. I've put this here to get a discussion on why it wouldn't be {1} rather than an edit war on it getting changed back to {X}. I understand that Gravemother technically gives Encore {X} where X is the mana value, but there is another ability later which uses X as well and since the mana value is 1, for the sake of not being potentially confusing,Encore {1} is better. Especially since there is nothing that specifies what Encore {X} is on the card, just that it has Encore {X}.

^ I don't know the rules on that. Does it get 'Encore {X} where X is mana value' or does it actually get 'Encore {1}'  ? I think we should double check that once it's on the gatherer.