Murders at Karlov Manor/Card comparisons: Difference between revisions

From MTG Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
>Neoheart
No edit summary
 
(9 intermediate revisions by 6 users not shown)
Line 6: Line 6:
|sub4 = Art Series
|sub4 = Art Series
|sub5 = Puzzles
|sub5 = Puzzles
|sub6 = The Case of the Three Blade Knife
}}
}}
Cards from ''[[Murders at Karlov Manor]]'' as compared to cards from earlier sets.
Cards from ''[[Murders at Karlov Manor]]'' as compared to cards from earlier sets.
Line 12: Line 13:
*<c>Airtight Alibi</c> is strictly better than <c>Feral Invocation</c> and <c>Maze's Mantle</c>.
*<c>Airtight Alibi</c> is strictly better than <c>Feral Invocation</c> and <c>Maze's Mantle</c>.
*<c>Analyze the Pollen</c> is strictly better than <c>Lay of the Land</c>.
*<c>Analyze the Pollen</c> is strictly better than <c>Lay of the Land</c>.
*{{card|Behind the Mask}} is strictly better than {{card|Relic's Roar}}.
*{{card|Case of the Uneaten Feast}} is strictly better than {{card|Ajani's Welcome}}.
*{{card|Cerebral Confiscation}} is strictly better than {{card|Dark Inquiry}} and {{card|Deception}}.
*<c>Demand Answers</c> is strictly better than <c>Thrill of Possibility</c>, <c>Tormenting Voice</c>, and <c>Wild Guess</c>.
*<c>Demand Answers</c> is strictly better than <c>Thrill of Possibility</c>, <c>Tormenting Voice</c>, and <c>Wild Guess</c>.
*{{Card|Dramatic Accusation}} is strictly better than {{card|Castaway's Despair}}, {{card|Charmed Sleep}}, {{Card|Claustrophobia}}, {{card|Dehydration}}, {{card|Glimmerdust Nap}}, {{card|Merseine}}, {{card|Paralyzing Grasp}}, {{card|Sleep Paralysis}}, {{card|Thirst}}, and {{Card|Waterknot}}.
*{{Card|Escape Tunnel}} is strictly better than {{Card|Evolving Wilds}} and {{Card|Terramorphic Expanse}}.
*<c>Expose the Culprit</c> is strictly better than <c>Break Open</c>.
*<c>Expose the Culprit</c> is strictly better than <c>Break Open</c>.
*{{Card|Extract a Confession}} is strictly better than {{Card|Cruel Edict}}.
*{{Card|Gearbane Orangutan}} is strictly better than {{Card|Manic Vandal}}.
*{{card|Get a Leg Up}} is strictly better than {{card|Might of the Masses}}.
*{{card|Hard-Hitting Question}} is strictly better than {{card|Aggressive Instinct}}, {{card|Prey Upon}}, and {{card|Rabid Bite}}.
*<c>Long Goodbye</c> is strictly better than <c>Eliminate</c>.
*<c>Long Goodbye</c> is strictly better than <c>Eliminate</c>.
*{{card|Macabre Reconstruction}} is strictly better than {{card|Dutiful Return}} and {{card|March of the Returned}}.
*<c>Not on My Watch</c> is strictly better than <c>Eightfold Maze</c>, <c>Excise</c>, <c>Immolating Glare</c>, <c>Just Fate</c>, <c>Kill Shot</c>, and <c>Rebuke</c>.
*<c>Not on My Watch</c> is strictly better than <c>Eightfold Maze</c>, <c>Excise</c>, <c>Immolating Glare</c>, <c>Just Fate</c>, <c>Kill Shot</c>, and <c>Rebuke</c>.
*{{card|On the Job}} is strictly better than {{card|Inspired Charge}}.
*{{card|Slice from the Shadows}} is strictly better than {{card|Death Wind}}.
*<c>Steamcore Scholar</c> is strictly better than <c>Elite Instructor</c> and <c>Screeching Drake</c>.
*{{Card|Unauthorized Exit}} is strictly better than {{Card|Disperse}} and {{Card|Drown in Shapelessness}}.
*The [[Tapland#Surveil lands|Surveil dual lands]] are strictly better than the [[Tapland#Land-type taplands|land-type taplands]] first printed in ''[[Dominaria United]]''.


===Vanillas and French vanillas===
===Vanillas and French vanillas===
Line 21: Line 37:
*<c>Axebane Ferox</c> is strictly better than <c>Axebane Beast</c>, <c>Broodhunter Wurm</c>, <c>Durkwood Boars</c>, <c>Ferocious Zheng</c>, <c>Golden Bear</c>, <c>Nettle Swine</c>, <c>Order of the Sacred Bell</c>, <c>Rowan Treefolk</c>, <c>Rumbling Baloth</c>, <c>Southern Elephant</c>, and <c>Wild Ceratok</c>.
*<c>Axebane Ferox</c> is strictly better than <c>Axebane Beast</c>, <c>Broodhunter Wurm</c>, <c>Durkwood Boars</c>, <c>Ferocious Zheng</c>, <c>Golden Bear</c>, <c>Nettle Swine</c>, <c>Order of the Sacred Bell</c>, <c>Rowan Treefolk</c>, <c>Rumbling Baloth</c>, <c>Southern Elephant</c>, and <c>Wild Ceratok</c>.
*<c>Benthic Criminologists</c> is strictly better than <c>Ancient Carp</c> and <c>Armored Cancrix</c>.
*<c>Benthic Criminologists</c> is strictly better than <c>Ancient Carp</c> and <c>Armored Cancrix</c>.
*<c>Homicide Investigator</c> is strictly better than <c>Cabal Evangel</c>, <c>Dakmor Scorpion</c>, <c>Gutter Skulk</c>, <c>Headless Horseman</c>, <c>Krovikan Scoundrel</c>, <c>Queen's Bay Soldier</c>, <c>Scathe Zombies</c>, <c>Skeletal Snake</c>, <c>Walking Corpse</c>, and <c>Wei Infantry</c>.
*<c>Marketwatch Phantom</c> is strictly better than <c>Fresh Volunteers</c>, <c>Glory Seeker</c>, <c>Knight Errant</c>, <c>Pearled Unicorn</c>, <c>Silvercoat Lion</c>, <c>Squire</c>, and <c>Traveling Philosopher</c>.
*<c>Pyrotechnic Performer</c> is strictly better than <c>Balduvian Barbarians</c>, <c>Defiant Khenra</c>, <c>Falkenrath Reaver</c>, <c>Fearless Halberdier</c>, <c>Feral Maaka</c>, <c>Goblin Assailant</c>, <c>Goblin Bully</c>, <c>Goblin Cavaliers</c>, <c>Goblin Hero</c>, <c>Goblin Piker</c>, <c>Goblin Roughrider</c>, <c>Gray Ogre</c>, <c>Independent Troops</c>, <c>Leopard-Spotted Jiao</c>, <c>Raging Bull</c>, and <c>Swab Goblin</c>.
*<c>Rakdos, Patron of Chaos</c> is strictly better than <c>Barktooth Warbeard</c>.
*<c>Rakdos, Patron of Chaos</c> is strictly better than <c>Barktooth Warbeard</c>.
*<c>Sanitation Automaton</c> is strictly better than <c>Alpha Myr</c>, <c>Bronze Sable</c>, and <c>Field Creeper</c>.
*<c>Sharp-Eyed Rookie</c> is strictly better than <c>Balduvian Bears</c>, <c>Barbary Apes</c>, <c>Bear Cub</c>, <c>Cylian Elf</c>, <c>Forest Bear</c>, <c>Greenwood Sentinel</c>, <c>Grizzly Bears</c>, and <c>Runeclaw Bear</c>.
*<c>Steamcore Scholar</c> is strictly better than <c>Wind Drake</c>.
*<c>Topiary Panther</c> is strictly better than <c>Alpha Tyrranax</c>, <c>Barbtooth Wurm</c>, <c>Canopy Gorger</c>, <c>Craw Wurm</c>, <c>Earthshaking Si</c>, <c>Giant Warthog</c>, <c>Moss Kami</c>, <c>Tusked Colossodon</c>, <c>Vulpine Goliath</c>, and <c>Yavimaya Wurm</c>.
*<c>Topiary Panther</c> is strictly better than <c>Alpha Tyrranax</c>, <c>Barbtooth Wurm</c>, <c>Canopy Gorger</c>, <c>Craw Wurm</c>, <c>Earthshaking Si</c>, <c>Giant Warthog</c>, <c>Moss Kami</c>, <c>Tusked Colossodon</c>, <c>Vulpine Goliath</c>, and <c>Yavimaya Wurm</c>.
*{{Card|Unyielding Gatekeeper}} is strictly better than vanilla 3/1s for {{1}}{{W}} ({{Card|Blade of the Sixth Pride}}, {{Card|Cliffhaven Sell-Sword}}, {{Card|Devilthorn Fox}}, {{Card|Dromoka Warrior}}, {{Card|Impostor of the Sixth Pride}}, {{Card|Knight of New Benalia}}, {{Card|Oreskos Swiftclaw}}, {{Card|Prowling Caracal}}, {{Card|Raptor Companion}}, and {{Card|Savai Sabertooth}}).
*<c>Vein Ripper</c> is strictly better than <c>Bogstomper</c>.
*<c>Vitu-Ghazi Inspector</c> is strictly better than <c>Canopy Spider</c>.
*<c>Wojek Investigator</c> is strictly better than <c>Abbey Griffin</c>, <c>Affa Protector</c>, <c>Alabaster Kirin</c>, <c>Alaborn Trooper</c>, <c>Border Guard</c>, <c>Alert Shu Infantry</c>, <c>Armored Griffin</c>, <c>Chapel Geist</c>, <c>Dawn Gryff</c>, <c>Diving Griffin</c>, <c>Eagle of the Watch</c>, <c>Exultant Skymarcher</c>, <c>Femeref Scouts</c>, <c>Foot Soldiers</c>, <c>Ghirapur Osprey</c>, <c>Great Hart</c>, <c>Griffin Sentinel</c>, <c>Keen-Eyed Archers</c>, <c>Keepers of the Faith</c>, <c>Makindi Griffin</c>, <c>Pearled Unicorn</c>, <c>Pillarfield Ox</c>, <c>Regal Unicorn</c>, <c>Shadow Glider</c>, <c>Shu Foot Soldiers</c>, <c>Skyhunter Prowler</c>, <c>Spotted Griffin</c>, <c>Standing Troops</c>, <c>Sunspire Griffin</c>, <c>Those Who Serve</c>, and <c>Wild Griffin</c>.
*<c>Wojek Investigator</c> is strictly better than <c>Abbey Griffin</c>, <c>Affa Protector</c>, <c>Alabaster Kirin</c>, <c>Alaborn Trooper</c>, <c>Border Guard</c>, <c>Alert Shu Infantry</c>, <c>Armored Griffin</c>, <c>Chapel Geist</c>, <c>Dawn Gryff</c>, <c>Diving Griffin</c>, <c>Eagle of the Watch</c>, <c>Exultant Skymarcher</c>, <c>Femeref Scouts</c>, <c>Foot Soldiers</c>, <c>Ghirapur Osprey</c>, <c>Great Hart</c>, <c>Griffin Sentinel</c>, <c>Keen-Eyed Archers</c>, <c>Keepers of the Faith</c>, <c>Makindi Griffin</c>, <c>Pearled Unicorn</c>, <c>Pillarfield Ox</c>, <c>Regal Unicorn</c>, <c>Shadow Glider</c>, <c>Shu Foot Soldiers</c>, <c>Skyhunter Prowler</c>, <c>Spotted Griffin</c>, <c>Standing Troops</c>, <c>Sunspire Griffin</c>, <c>Those Who Serve</c>, and <c>Wild Griffin</c>.
==Strictly worse==


==Functional reprints==
==Functional reprints==
*{{card|Fanatical Strength}} is a functional reprint of {{card|Predator's Strike}} and {{card|Staggering Size}}.
*{{card|Fanatical Strength}} is a functional reprint of {{card|Predator's Strike}} and {{card|Staggering Size}}.
*<c>Novice Inspector</c> is a functional reprint of <c>Thraben Inspector</c>.
*<c>Novice Inspector</c> is a functional reprint of <c>Thraben Inspector</c>.
===Colorshifted===


[[Category:Card comparisons]]
[[Category:Card comparisons]]

Latest revision as of 14:44, 4 April 2024

Murders at Karlov Manor/Card comparisons
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

Cards from Murders at Karlov Manor as compared to cards from earlier sets.

Strictly better

Vanillas and French vanillas

Functional reprints