Phyrexia: All Will Be One/Card comparisons: Difference between revisions
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
>Mrsalt05 No edit summary |
(Swamp mosquito has a different type of poison trigger) |
||
(14 intermediate revisions by 9 users not shown) | |||
Line 6: | Line 6: | ||
|sub4 = Jumpstart | |sub4 = Jumpstart | ||
|sub5 = Welcome booster | |sub5 = Welcome booster | ||
|sub6 = Art Series | |||
}} | }} | ||
Cards from ''[[Phyrexia: All Will Be One]]'' as compared to cards from earlier sets. | Cards from ''[[Phyrexia: All Will Be One]]'' as compared to cards from earlier sets. | ||
==Strictly better== | ==Strictly better== | ||
*<c>Adaptive Sporesinger</c> is strictly better than <c>Yeva's Forcemage</c>. | |||
*{{Card|Annihilating Glare}} is strictly better than {{Card|Bone Splinters}}, {{Card|Powerstone Fracture}}, and {{Card|Spark Harvest}}. | |||
*<c>Anoint with Affliction</c> is strictly better than <c>Smother</c>. | *<c>Anoint with Affliction</c> is strictly better than <c>Smother</c>. | ||
*{{Card| | *{{Card|Aspirant's Ascent}} is strictly better than {{Card|Jump}}. | ||
*{{Card|Black Sun's Twilight}} is strictly better than {{Card|Death Wind}} | |||
*<c>Blue Sun's Twilight</c> is strictly better than <c>Entrancing Melody</c>. | *<c>Blue Sun's Twilight</c> is strictly better than <c>Entrancing Melody</c>. | ||
*{{Card| | *{{Card|Bring the Ending}} is strictly better than {{Card|Quench}}. | ||
*{{Card| | *{{Card|Carnivorous Canopy}} is strictly better than {{Card|Wing Snare}}. | ||
*{{Card|Distorted Curiosity}} is strictly better than {{Card|Counsel of the Soratami}}, {{Card|Divination}}, and {{Card|Touch of Brilliance}}. | |||
*<c>Duelist of Deep Faith</c> is strictly better than <c>Pouncing Lynx</c>. | |||
*<c>Dune Mover</c> is strictly better than <c>Campus Guide</c>. | |||
*<c>Experimental Augury</c> is strictly better than <c>Steady Progress</c>, <c>Contentious Plan</c> and <c>Anticipate</c>. | *<c>Experimental Augury</c> is strictly better than <c>Steady Progress</c>, <c>Contentious Plan</c> and <c>Anticipate</c>. | ||
*{{Card|Feed the Infection}} is strictly better than {{Card|Ambition's Cost}} and {{Card|Ancient Craving}}. | *{{Card|Feed the Infection}} is strictly better than {{Card|Ambition's Cost}} and {{Card|Ancient Craving}}. | ||
*{{Card|Free from Flesh}} is strictly better than {{Card|Bull Rush}}. | |||
*{{Card|Gleeful Demolition}} is strictly better than {{Card|Kuldotha Rebirth}}. | *{{Card|Gleeful Demolition}} is strictly better than {{Card|Kuldotha Rebirth}}. | ||
*{{Card|Hexgold Slash}} is strictly better than {{Card|Breath of Fire}}. | |||
*{{Card|Infectious Bite}} is strictly better than {{Card|Aggressive Instinct}} and {{Card|Rabid Bite}}. | *{{Card|Infectious Bite}} is strictly better than {{Card|Aggressive Instinct}} and {{Card|Rabid Bite}}. | ||
*{{Card|Jawbone Duelist}} is strictly better than {{Card|Fencing Ace}}. | *{{Card|Jawbone Duelist}} is strictly better than {{Card|Fencing Ace}}. | ||
*{{Card|Mercurial Spelldancer}} is strictly better than {{Card|Hazy Homunculus}} | *<c>Malcator's Watcher</c> is strictly better than <c>Surveilling Sprite</c> and <c>Palace Familiar</c>. | ||
*{{Card|Mesmerizing Dose}} is strictly better than {{Card|Claustrophobia}} and {{Card|Waterknot}}. | *<c>Maze's Mantle</c> is strictly better than <c>Feral Invocation</c> | ||
*{{Card|Mercurial Spelldancer}} is strictly better than {{Card|Deeptread Merrow}}, {{Card|Furtive Homunculus}}, {{Card|Hazy Homunculus}}, {{Card|Metathran Soldier}}, {{Card|Relic Runner}}, {{Card|River Merfolk}}, and {{Card|Sneaky Homunculus}}. | |||
*{{Card|Mesmerizing Dose}} is strictly better than {{Card|Claustrophobia}}, {{Card|Merseine}} and {{Card|Waterknot}}. | |||
*{{Card|Monument to Perfection}} is strictly better than {{Card|Journeyer's Kite}}. | *{{Card|Monument to Perfection}} is strictly better than {{Card|Journeyer's Kite}}. | ||
*{{Card|The Mycosynth Gardens}} is strictly better than {{Card|Painted Bluffs}}, {{Card|Shimmering Grotto}}, and {{Card|Unknown Shores}}. | *{{Card|The Mycosynth Gardens}} is strictly better than {{Card|Painted Bluffs}}, {{Card|Shimmering Grotto}}, and {{Card|Unknown Shores}}. | ||
*{{Card|Phyrexian Atlas}} is strictly better than {{Card|Manalith}}. | *{{Card|Phyrexian Atlas}} is strictly better than {{Card|Celestial Prism}}, {{Card|Manalith}}, {{Card|Phyrexian Lens}}, {{Card|Sol Grail}}, the ''[[Invasion]]'' cameos (e.g. {{Card|Bloodstone Cameo}}), and the ''[[Shards of Alara]]'' obelisks (e.g. {{Card|Obelisk of Bant}}). | ||
*{{Card|Phyrexian Vindicator}} is strictly better than {{Card|Dawn Elemental}}. | *{{Card|Phyrexian Vindicator}} is strictly better than {{Card|Dawn Elemental}}. | ||
*<c>Planar Disruption</c> is strictly better than <c>Pacifism</c>, <c>Nahiri's Binding</c>, and <c>Arrest</c>. | *<c>Planar Disruption</c> is strictly better than <c>Pacifism</c>, <c>Nahiri's Binding</c>, and <c>Arrest</c>. | ||
*<c>Quicksilver Fisher</c> is strictly better than <c>Sky-Eel School</c>. | |||
*{{Card|Rebel Salvo}} is strictly better than {{Card|Bombard}}, {{Card|Command the Storm}}, {{Card|Electrify}}, {{Card|Final Flare}}, and {{Card|Soul Sear}}. | |||
*{{Card|Reject Imperfection}} is strictly better than {{Card|Cancel}} and {{Card|Mystic Denial}}. | |||
*<c>Sawblade Scamp</c> is strictly better than <c>Mountain Bandit</c> and <c>Raging Goblin</c>. | *<c>Sawblade Scamp</c> is strictly better than <c>Mountain Bandit</c> and <c>Raging Goblin</c>. | ||
*{{Card|Serum Snare}} is strictly better than {{Card|Disperse}}. | *{{Card|Serum Snare}} is strictly better than {{Card|Disperse}}. | ||
*{{Card| | *{{Card|Skyscythe Engulfer}} is strictly better than {{Card|Alpha Tyrranax}}, {{Card|Archweaver}}, {{Card|Barbtooth Wurm}}, {{Card|Canopy Gorger}}, {{Card|Craw Wurm}}, {{Card|Earthshaking Si}}, {{Card|Giant Warthog}}, {{Card|Moss Kami}}, {{Card|Tusked Colossodon}}, {{Card|Vulpine Goliath}}, and {{Card|Yavimaya Wurm}}. | ||
*{{Card| | *{{Card|Sword of Forge and Frontier}} is strictly better than <c>Heavy Mattock</c>. | ||
*{{Card|Thirsting Roots}} is strictly better than {{Card|Lay of the Land}}. | |||
*{{Card|Tyvar's Stand}} is strictly better than {{Card|Mortal's Resolve}}, {{Card|Untamed Might}}, and {{Card|Withstand Death}}. | |||
*{{Card|Unnatural Restoration}} is strictly better than {{Card|Nature's Spiral}}. | |||
*<c>Vanish Into Eternity</c> is strictly better than <c>Ironwright's Cleansing</c> and <c>Fate Forgotten</c>. | |||
*{{Card|Vat Emergence}} is strictly better than {{Card|Rise Again}}. | |||
*{{Card|Vivisurgeon's Insight}} is strictly better than {{Card|Tezzeret's Ambition}}. | |||
=== Vanillas and French vanillas === | ===Vanillas and French vanillas=== | ||
*{{Card|Bilious Skulldweller}} is strictly better than 1/1 creatures with deathtouch for {{B}} ({{Card|Hired Poisoner}}, {{Card|Pharika's Chosen}}, and {{Card|Typhoid Rats}}). | |||
* {{Card|Bilious Skulldweller}} is strictly better than 1/1 creatures with deathtouch for {{B}} ({{Card|Hired Poisoner}}, {{Card|Pharika's Chosen}}, and {{Card|Typhoid Rats}}). | |||
*{{Card|Bladed Ambassador}} is strictly better than 3/1 {{1}}{{W}} vanillas ({{Card|Blade of the Sixth Pride}}, {{Card|Cliffhaven Sell-Sword}}, {{Card|Devilthorn Fox}}, {{Card|Dromoka Warrior}}, {{Card|Knight of New Benalia}}, {{Card|Oreskos Swiftclaw}}, {{Card|Prowling Caracal}}, {{Card|Raptor Companion}}, and {{Card|Savai Sabertooth}}). | *{{Card|Bladed Ambassador}} is strictly better than 3/1 {{1}}{{W}} vanillas ({{Card|Blade of the Sixth Pride}}, {{Card|Cliffhaven Sell-Sword}}, {{Card|Devilthorn Fox}}, {{Card|Dromoka Warrior}}, {{Card|Knight of New Benalia}}, {{Card|Oreskos Swiftclaw}}, {{Card|Prowling Caracal}}, {{Card|Raptor Companion}}, and {{Card|Savai Sabertooth}}). | ||
*{{Card|Bloated Contaminator}} is strictly better than {{Card|Alpine Grizzly}}, {{Card|Centaur Courser}}, {{Card|Elvish Ranger}}, {{Card|Gorilla Warrior}}, {{Card|Harrier Naga}}, {{Card|Murasa Brute}}, {{Card|Nessian Courser}}, {{Card|Spined Karok}}, and {{Card|Wildwood Patrol}}. | *{{Card|Bloated Contaminator}} is strictly better than {{Card|Alpine Grizzly}}, {{Card|Centaur Courser}}, {{Card|Elvish Ranger}}, {{Card|Gorilla Warrior}}, {{Card|Harrier Naga}}, {{Card|Megatherium}}, {{Card|Murasa Brute}}, {{Card|Nessian Courser}}, {{Card|Spined Karok}}, and {{Card|Wildwood Patrol}}. | ||
*{{Card|Bonepicker Skirge}} is strictly better than 2/1 flying creatures for {{2}}{{B}} ({{Card|Dusk Imp}}, {{Card|Feral Shadow}}, {{Card|Gloomhunter}}, {{Card|Kelinore Bat}} and {{Card|Moaning Spirit}}). | *{{Card|Bonepicker Skirge}} is strictly better than {{Card|Belbe's Percher}}, {{Card|Carrion Crow}}, {{Card|Tethered Skirge}}, 2/1 flying creatures for {{2}}{{B}} ({{Card|Dusk Imp}}, {{Card|Feral Shadow}}, {{Card|Gloomhunter}}, {{Card|Kelinore Bat}} and {{Card|Moaning Spirit}}). | ||
*<c>Chimney Rabble</c> is strictly better than <c>Hostile Minotaur</c>. | |||
*<c>Cruel Grimnarch</c> is strictly better than <c>Feral Abomination</c>. | |||
*{{Card|Furnace Punisher}} is strictly better than {{Card|Boggart Brute}}. | *{{Card|Furnace Punisher}} is strictly better than {{Card|Boggart Brute}}. | ||
*<c>Incisor Glider</c> is strictly better than 1/3 flying creatures for {{1}}{{W}} (<c>Concordia Pegasus</c> and <c>Skyblade of the Legion</c>). | *<c>Incisor Glider</c> is strictly better than 1/3 flying creatures for {{1}}{{W}} (<c>Concordia Pegasus</c> and <c>Skyblade of the Legion</c>). | ||
*{{Card|Orthodoxy Enforcer}} is strictly better than 2/4 {{3}}{{W}} vanillas ({{Card|Foot Soldiers}}, {{Card|Great Hart}} and {{Card|Pillarfield Ox}}). | |||
*{{Card|Resistance Skywarden}} is strictly better than {{Card|Earth Elemental}}, {{Card|Fire Elemental}}, {{Card|Frost Ogre}}, {{Card|Hulking Cyclops}}, and {{Card|Shatterskull Recruit}}. | |||
*{{Card|Sawblade Scamp}} and {{Card|Vindictive Flamestoker}} are strictly better than 1/1 {{R}} vanillas (<c>Dwarven Trader</c> and <c>Mons's Goblin Raiders</c>). | *{{Card|Sawblade Scamp}} and {{Card|Vindictive Flamestoker}} are strictly better than 1/1 {{R}} vanillas (<c>Dwarven Trader</c> and <c>Mons's Goblin Raiders</c>). | ||
*{{Card|Swooping Lookout}} is strictly better than {{Card|Rustwing Falcon}} and 1/1 flying creatures for {{W}} ({{Card|Aven Skirmisher}}, {{Card|Kitesail Scout}}, {{Card|Lantern Kami}}, and {{Card|Suntail Hawk}}). | *{{Card|Swooping Lookout}} is strictly better than {{Card|Rustwing Falcon}} and 1/1 flying creatures for {{W}} ({{Card|Aven Skirmisher}}, {{Card|Kitesail Scout}}, {{Card|Lantern Kami}}, and {{Card|Suntail Hawk}}). | ||
Line 45: | Line 68: | ||
==Strictly worse== | ==Strictly worse== | ||
*{{Card|Distorted Curiosity}} is strictly worse than {{Card|Ancestral Recall}}. | |||
*<c>Sinew Dancer</c> is strictly worse than <c>Gideon's Lawkeeper</c> and <c>Goldmeadow Harrier</c>. | *<c>Sinew Dancer</c> is strictly worse than <c>Gideon's Lawkeeper</c> and <c>Goldmeadow Harrier</c>. | ||
[[Category:Card comparisons]] | [[Category:Card comparisons]] |
Latest revision as of 02:12, 12 September 2023
Phyrexia: All Will Be One/Card comparisons
Cards from Phyrexia: All Will Be One as compared to cards from earlier sets.
Strictly better
- Adaptive Sporesinger is strictly better than Yeva's Forcemage.
- Annihilating Glare is strictly better than Bone Splinters, Powerstone Fracture, and Spark Harvest.
- Anoint with Affliction is strictly better than Smother.
- Aspirant's Ascent is strictly better than Jump.
- Black Sun's Twilight is strictly better than Death Wind
- Blue Sun's Twilight is strictly better than Entrancing Melody.
- Bring the Ending is strictly better than Quench.
- Carnivorous Canopy is strictly better than Wing Snare.
- Distorted Curiosity is strictly better than Counsel of the Soratami, Divination, and Touch of Brilliance.
- Duelist of Deep Faith is strictly better than Pouncing Lynx.
- Dune Mover is strictly better than Campus Guide.
- Experimental Augury is strictly better than Steady Progress, Contentious Plan and Anticipate.
- Feed the Infection is strictly better than Ambition's Cost and Ancient Craving.
- Free from Flesh is strictly better than Bull Rush.
- Gleeful Demolition is strictly better than Kuldotha Rebirth.
- Hexgold Slash is strictly better than Breath of Fire.
- Infectious Bite is strictly better than Aggressive Instinct and Rabid Bite.
- Jawbone Duelist is strictly better than Fencing Ace.
- Malcator's Watcher is strictly better than Surveilling Sprite and Palace Familiar.
- Maze's Mantle is strictly better than Feral Invocation
- Mercurial Spelldancer is strictly better than Deeptread Merrow, Furtive Homunculus, Hazy Homunculus, Metathran Soldier, Relic Runner, River Merfolk, and Sneaky Homunculus.
- Mesmerizing Dose is strictly better than Claustrophobia, Merseine and Waterknot.
- Monument to Perfection is strictly better than Journeyer's Kite.
- The Mycosynth Gardens is strictly better than Painted Bluffs, Shimmering Grotto, and Unknown Shores.
- Phyrexian Atlas is strictly better than Celestial Prism, Manalith, Phyrexian Lens, Sol Grail, the Invasion cameos (e.g. Bloodstone Cameo), and the Shards of Alara obelisks (e.g. Obelisk of Bant).
- Phyrexian Vindicator is strictly better than Dawn Elemental.
- Planar Disruption is strictly better than Pacifism, Nahiri's Binding, and Arrest.
- Quicksilver Fisher is strictly better than Sky-Eel School.
- Rebel Salvo is strictly better than Bombard, Command the Storm, Electrify, Final Flare, and Soul Sear.
- Reject Imperfection is strictly better than Cancel and Mystic Denial.
- Sawblade Scamp is strictly better than Mountain Bandit and Raging Goblin.
- Serum Snare is strictly better than Disperse.
- Skyscythe Engulfer is strictly better than Alpha Tyrranax, Archweaver, Barbtooth Wurm, Canopy Gorger, Craw Wurm, Earthshaking Si, Giant Warthog, Moss Kami, Tusked Colossodon, Vulpine Goliath, and Yavimaya Wurm.
- Sword of Forge and Frontier is strictly better than Heavy Mattock.
- Thirsting Roots is strictly better than Lay of the Land.
- Tyvar's Stand is strictly better than Mortal's Resolve, Untamed Might, and Withstand Death.
- Unnatural Restoration is strictly better than Nature's Spiral.
- Vanish Into Eternity is strictly better than Ironwright's Cleansing and Fate Forgotten.
- Vat Emergence is strictly better than Rise Again.
- Vivisurgeon's Insight is strictly better than Tezzeret's Ambition.
Vanillas and French vanillas
- Bilious Skulldweller is strictly better than 1/1 creatures with deathtouch for (Hired Poisoner, Pharika's Chosen, and Typhoid Rats).
- Bladed Ambassador is strictly better than 3/1 vanillas (Blade of the Sixth Pride, Cliffhaven Sell-Sword, Devilthorn Fox, Dromoka Warrior, Knight of New Benalia, Oreskos Swiftclaw, Prowling Caracal, Raptor Companion, and Savai Sabertooth).
- Bloated Contaminator is strictly better than Alpine Grizzly, Centaur Courser, Elvish Ranger, Gorilla Warrior, Harrier Naga, Megatherium, Murasa Brute, Nessian Courser, Spined Karok, and Wildwood Patrol.
- Bonepicker Skirge is strictly better than Belbe's Percher, Carrion Crow, Tethered Skirge, 2/1 flying creatures for (Dusk Imp, Feral Shadow, Gloomhunter, Kelinore Bat and Moaning Spirit).
- Chimney Rabble is strictly better than Hostile Minotaur.
- Cruel Grimnarch is strictly better than Feral Abomination.
- Furnace Punisher is strictly better than Boggart Brute.
- Incisor Glider is strictly better than 1/3 flying creatures for (Concordia Pegasus and Skyblade of the Legion).
- Orthodoxy Enforcer is strictly better than 2/4 vanillas (Foot Soldiers, Great Hart and Pillarfield Ox).
- Resistance Skywarden is strictly better than Earth Elemental, Fire Elemental, Frost Ogre, Hulking Cyclops, and Shatterskull Recruit.
- Sawblade Scamp and Vindictive Flamestoker are strictly better than 1/1 vanillas (Dwarven Trader and Mons's Goblin Raiders).
- Swooping Lookout is strictly better than Rustwing Falcon and 1/1 flying creatures for (Aven Skirmisher, Kitesail Scout, Lantern Kami, and Suntail Hawk).
- Urabrask's Anointer is strictly better than 4/2 creatures for (Lizard Warrior and Viashino Warrior).
Strictly worse
- Distorted Curiosity is strictly worse than Ancestral Recall.
- Sinew Dancer is strictly worse than Gideon's Lawkeeper and Goldmeadow Harrier.